
Suddenly I was caught up in the spirit and dragged before the judgment seat of the Judge; and here the light was so bright, and those who stood around were so radiant, that I cast myself upon the ground and did not dare to look up. Asked who and what I was, I replied: “I am a Christian.” But He who presided said: “You lie. You are a follower of the Washington Review of Books and not of Christ. For ‘where your treasure is, there will your heart be also.’”
Links:
Reviews:
In the Wall Street Journal, Dana Gioia reviews a volume of Frost’s letters (The Letters of Robert Frost, Volume 4: 1937–1946, edited by Robert Bernard Hass, Henry Atmore, Donald Sheehy, and Mark Richardson, September):
Frost knew his own flaws and failures. To his first biographer, they made him a moral monster. Never ceasing to admire Frost’s poetry, Thompson could not forgive the man for not living up to his own legend. To anyone reading the poet’s letters, however, Frost simply seems human, with both admirable and unworthy qualities. He was vain, cagey and calculating. He was also amusing, generous and loyal. Frost was a loving but neglectful husband, a devoted but remote father. Like many great writers—Rousseau, Byron, Tolstoy, Joyce and probably Shakespeare—the young Frost was too distracted for family life. The older Frost attempted to make amends. He diligently helped his children, but they were already locked in their sad destinies. After his son’s suicide, Frost wrote mournfully: “I took the wrong way with him. I tried many ways and every single one of them was wrong.”
Frost was of two minds about everything. “I am neither happy nor unhappy,” he wrote to Untermeyer. “I can’t seem to determine which I am.” That habitual ambivalence characterizes his most famous poems. (“Some say the world will end in fire, / Some say in ice.”) He mischievously took both sides of every argument. He wanted to follow both roads in the fork. He saw equal reasons to mend a wall or let it fall. He preferred contradictions to conclusions. That disinterested and dialectical turn of mind animated his poetry. His wasn’t a reliable method to raise a large family. Double-mindedness, however, remains the best way to understand Frost.
[I think of this from “‘Out, Out—’”:
. . . At the word, the saw,
As if to prove saws knew what supper meant,
Leaped out at the boy’s hand, or seemed to leap—
He must have given the hand. . . .
Or this, from “The Wood-Pile”:
I paused and said, “I will turn back from here.
No, I will go on farther—and we shall see.”
The contradictions take the place of conclusions, yes, but in many of his poems (as in “Fire and Ice,” which Gioia quotes) the initial situation is presented in two ways, and the poem never resolves which is the correct approach or the correct way of viewing it. That “we shall see” is total uncertainty. See what? If the speaker turned back, would he not also see in this vague general sense without a specific object? Only from this initial aporia can Frost take the poems in the directions he wants. —Steve]
In the TLS, Sophie Gee reviews a book about the writing of Gulliver’s Travels (The Twitnam Summer: Friendship, Satire and the Writing of “Gulliver’s Travels,” by Hester Grant, August 10, 2027) and a new edition thereof (Gulliver’s Travels: The Cambridge Anniversary Edition, edited by David Womersley, April):
The basic paradox of Swift, Pope and Gay is the relative harmony and domestic regularity of their lives, and the fury, explosive imaginative vision and bitter resentments of their writing. Swift had plenty of money and powerful, generous friends, both in England and in Ireland. Three women, Esther Johnson, Rebecca Dingley and Esther Vanhomrigh, were, moreover, devoting their lives to ensuring his care and comfort. The question that kept occurring to me as I read about these three men and their remarkably comfortable, privileged lives, is: why were they so attached to telling stories about disappointment, rejection and disaffection? In Swift’s greatest work, he doesn’t write about friendship, but about solitude, loneliness and intellectual isolation. Pope does write about friendship—many of his best poems are addressed to friends whom he loved and admired—but there’s always a sting in the tail, and his most enduringly famous poem is a vituperative tirade about how awful and talentless almost everyone is.
[We linked to an earlier review of The Twitnam Summer in WRB—June 3, 2026 and an earlier review of the new Gulliver’s Travels edition in WRB—Aug. 12, 2026.
Flaubert: “Be regular and ordinary in your life like a bourgeois in order to be violent and original in your work.”
Having a remarkably comfortable, privileged life brings many advantages, but it hardly prevents disappointment, rejection, and disaffection. (“How small, of all that human hearts endure, / That part which having a remarkably comfortable, privileged life can cure!” as I believe the poem goes.) The artistic impulse also has a deep link to dissatisfaction—if you were satisfied you’d hardly be messing around with reinterpreting and representing (“re-presenting”) and everything else that goes into making art. And even life’s satisfactions have a way of inspiring artistic dissatisfaction; most of the nicest things I’ve ever written about my friends, or friendship in general, were motivated by anger and sadness that I was not physically with them at that moment. Even the argument of the Dunciad is not so much “look how awful and talentless almost everyone is” as it is “look how all these hacks and philistines and frauds are preventing the good artists—me and my friends—from flourishing.” —Steve]
In our sister publication on the Hudson, Katie Kadue reviews The Devils (dir. Ken Russell, 1971):
The heroic role Russell gives Grandier is a testament to his longstanding interest in the agonies and ecstasies of male celebrity. The historical Sister Jeanne—who wrote what de Certeau called a “lucid” spiritual autobiography and whose performance so convinced the inquisitor Jean-Joseph Surin, who does not appear in the film, that he himself claimed to be possessed—is reduced by Russell to a sad sex freak whose authorship is limited to lurid fantasies. What sympathy we may have for her nuns, the unwanted daughters of cash-poor aristocrats, is soon drowned out, like that for Philippe, by their frenzied shrieks. Jeanne’s ecstatic visions—washing a Grandier-cum-Christ figure’s feet with her hair, or caressing his wounds as he descends from the cross—are strikingly similar to those recounted by mystics like Catherine of Siena and Teresa of Avila, women who are, like Jeanne, easy to dismiss and pathologize as unserious and undersexed, but harder to understand. Madeleine, the Madonna to these whores, is the only female character offered dignity, and she earns it through devotion to her husband. In the films that followed The Devils—from Lisztomania (1975), an acid trip of a biopic about the Hungarian composer as a proto-rock star, to Altered States (1980), an acid trip of a morality tale about an ambitious medical researcher—Russell reiterated the thesis that it’s hard for a man to be a successful sexy genius. They’ll kill you for it, unless you can find the love of a good woman, and sometimes even then.
[Behind the paywall are even more links to the best and most interesting writing from the past few days, Upcoming books, What we’re reading, and Critical notes. Today’s specials:
Do men want smart women, or do they want hot women? I (a man, and therefore an expert) discuss
Is mass culture necessarily a passive culture?
A Poem by Edmund Spenser and how to introduce an image
If you’re interested in any of that, and if you want to support the WRB in making the lifelong task of literacy not take anyone’s entire day, please subscribe.
And if you’re already a subscriber, thank you very much. Why not share the WRB with your friends and acquaintances? The best way to support us is by subscribing, but the second-best is by sharing the WRB with other people. —Steve]



